# Silence and the Sacred Art of Questioning
In a small hermitage in the desert, Maulana Jalal al-Din Rumi was working with his disciples. At that moment, some travelers happened to pass along that road. Overcome by curiosity, they halted their journey and entered the hermitage grounds. There they saw disciples and students seated, while Maulana Sahib answered their questions. Both the questions and the answers were of a most peculiar sort. Seeing this, the travelers grew restless and departed, continuing on their way.
After years of traveling, that same band of travelers returned, and once again they stood at that place, watching to see what was happening. This time they saw only Maulana Rumi sitting alone—his disciples were nowhere to be found. Bewildered, they wondered: what had become of them? Where had they all gone? “What has happened?” they asked. Maulana smiled and said, “This was my work. These disciples held many questions within them; I answered every question they possessed. Now they have no more questions. So I told them: go forth. Just as I have done, return to your own places and do this same work with others. Should you encounter someone whose questions you cannot answer well, send them to me.”
The more questions dwell within our minds, the more scattered our thoughts become, the further we drift from the right path. When all questions finally dissolve from the heart, our minds return to that childhood state—when we were innocent, when no dark thoughts troubled us, when nothing in the world could disturb our peace. No great journey can be undertaken while the mind remains restless and distracted. Should we take a vow of silence and still the tongue, should we immerse ourselves in the endless stream of peaceful contemplation, then even the most beautiful words can be spoken without utterance, even the most wondrous hidden truths can be revealed without speech. This silence itself is the answer. It contains no words, it corresponds to no particular question. Silence brings us to such a state that much can be said without saying anything at all.
In our daily lives, we pass through countless troubles and entanglements. Many of these are such that we have no hand in their beginning or their end. They leave us bewildered and helpless. In such moments, only silence can come to our aid. We must wait for the storm to pass. This waiting is not easy, yet there is nothing else to be done.
The essence of every religious and philosophical tradition is this: to understand life. This work of understanding cannot be done amid noise and clamor. True realization does not come to a scattered heart. If our words flow like a river in swift current, then our silence runs as deep as the ocean. Words are like bullets from a gun. Once the bullet is fired, what value remains in the gun? The bullet still held back, still locked within the chamber, possesses far greater power and effect. Is not the archer who has not yet released his arrow—who keeps it at his side—more dangerous still? His power remains with him, to be wielded whenever he chooses. The word not yet spoken carries within it infinitely more meaning, both truth and consequence, than any word that has been released into the world.
The person in whose heart a thought lies hidden, never reaching the lips, is entirely freed from the possible dangers of that thought. And when people draw various meanings—or misreadings—from this enigmatic silence, according to their own inclinations, the master of the word bears no responsibility for those interpretations.
To resist the temptation to speak is truly very difficult, but those who manage this task enjoy comparatively greater power and peace of mind.