# Eternal in Disbelief The human creature lives suspended between two poles: belief and disbelief. Yet we do not oscillate freely between them. We are weighted, pulled, anchored by forces we barely comprehend. Some call these forces God, some call them nature, some call them accident. But the naming changes nothing of the weight itself. There exists a peculiar species of human—one that has made a home in disbelief. Not the aggressive disbelief of those who rage against what they reject, but a quieter kind: the disbelief that has settled into the bones, that has become indistinguishable from breath. This person does not shout their doubt. They carry it like a second shadow. What does such a person believe? This is the question that undoes the simple binary. For disbelief is not the absence of belief—it is a belief of its own. It is the faith that nothing merits absolute faith. It is the conviction that convictions are provisional, fragile, contingent upon the next wind that blows them. Consider the believer: they have made a bargain with certainty. They have said, "This, at least, is true," and in that utterance they have found peace. The price of this peace is high—it requires the surrender of question, the closing of certain doors. But the architecture of their inner world becomes stable. They can build upon it. The disbeliever has refused the bargain. No door is closed to them, but neither is any truly open. They stand in a corridor of infinite branching hallways, each one possible, none certain. This is not the vertigo of youth. This is the settled vertigo of maturity—the understanding that there is no ledge to step onto, only the air itself to walk upon, and somehow, miraculously, it holds. Is this a form of courage? Or a form of cowardice? The question itself is misguided. For disbelief that has become eternal—that has lived long enough to acquire the dignity of a stance—is neither brave nor cowardly. It is simply the shape that honesty takes when it has nowhere left to hide. The religious person looks at the disbeliever and sees emptiness. The disbeliever looks at the religious person and sees bondage. Both, perhaps, are seeing a reflection of their own deepest fear. The fear of emptiness. The fear of chains. But what if the deepest truth is not that we are bound or free, but that we are both and neither? That belief and disbelief are not opposites but partners in the slow work of becoming human? There is a moment—perhaps you have known it—when you stop fighting your doubts. You do not resolve them. You do not dissolve them. You simply cease to resist them. And in that moment of surrender, something strange occurs: the doubt ceases to feel like an intrusion. It becomes part of the landscape of your mind, as ordinary and necessary as the darkness that lets the stars be visible. This is the eternity of disbelief. Not a state of being empty, but a state of being full of possibility. Not a rejection of meaning, but a refusal to claim that meaning is given rather than made. The person who lives here—in this eternal disbelief—they do not despair. They do not exult. They simply continue. They make choices without certainty. They build meaning without foundations. They love without guarantee. And in this, they discover something that the believer and the skeptic alike often miss: that meaning does not require certainty to be real. That love does not need God to be sacred. That a life can be full, profound, and luminous precisely because nothing in it is guaranteed. The birds do not believe in the sky, yet they soar through it. We are not so different.

April 10, 2023 2 min read By Sushanta Paul

Why do I remain so restless, even possessing you as my own soul? And yet you are within reach, accessible, eternally present. As you manifest in the world's infinite forms, so too do you exist in this darkness when all forms fall away. You are breath, you are mind, you are the seer, the listener, the thinker, the knower, the rememberer — in countless ways, countless shapes, you reveal yourself as one undivided whole. In every moment of my daily life, in every act, you shine forth as knowledge, as power, as the doer itself.

Why do I strain to grasp you? You have already given yourself. Why do I speak your name so many times? You who are the named, you reveal yourself at every instant — I need only open my eyes to see you. O my Self, my I-ness, my everything, there is nothing more intimate than you, no one more intimate than you. You are the innermost. I have received what I desired. This is your love.

In every moment, in every pulse of life, your love. This love is not inference for my heart — it is direct, immediate experience. No need to guess, no need to prove. In my rising and sitting, in my every thought, my every step, my every deed — this love. In my seeing, my hearing, my touch, my smell, my taste — this love. In my reading books, in this very writing, in my speech — this love.

The beloved I seek, the dear one I desire — the one whom no one else loves as I do, the one I love most of all, the one with whom I can spend hour after hour, day after day in solitude and secrecy, the one whose presence fulfills every need — that person is you. You are so near, so intimate, so engaged, so tender in your care, as no one else is, as no one else could be. My sense of spiritual failure, my grievances against your grace — all of it should vanish now. Every longing of mine is satisfied; there is nothing left to desire.

Then if I am not at peace now, not happy now, what excuse remains for me? Will my long-cherished dreams of joy finally come true? Has the night of my sorrow ended? Who knew that in this thing I call my heart there dwells an infinite, unfathomable, bottomless love? Who knew that in it lived the motherhood of all mothers, the fatherhood of all fathers, the wifehood of all wives, the husbandhood of all husbands, the friendship of all friends? Who knew that this heart could embrace all the world, that to it all are kin? Who knew that this heart held within it the source of all peace, the source of all contentment, the source of all joy?

What have you shown me today, what have you made me hear, what hope have you granted, what promise have you given! I gaze toward your face. I wait to see what you will do with me next. There is nothing impossible for you. In your kingdom, I have heard, many wonders have occurred, many things that seemed impossible have come to pass. That you will make me a lover, drown me in love, wash away all my doubt and disbelief, all my lovelessness — even to one as faithless as I, this does not seem impossible. Let me see what you will do.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply